April 17th and 18th have been interesting days in the Nebraska State House. Not because 16 hours of discussion about tax law is ever compelling stuff, but because of the obvious hypocrisy, and stone headed stubbornness displayed by some of the Senators.
Yesterday was filled with talk about giving back $500 to every home owner in the state. Senator White made some compelling arguments, you ALMOST believed he truly had the best interest of all Nebraskans in mind when he pitched this amendment to LB 367 which is dealing with changing the taxes on construction materials, and change the motor vehicle tax. White spoke for most of yesterday, and into today about how almost all Nebraskans would benefit from this “tax cut” he even went so far as to claim that ALL his constituents demanded this action. Which begs the question. Are there no renters in Senator White’s district? Or are they just so stupid, they don’t realize this amendment wouldn’t affect them in the slightest?
The discussion really got rolling when bombastic, and (usually confusing and rambling) Senator Friend attempted to add an amendment that would repeal the estate tax
. Senator Friend claimed he wasn’t simply catering to his rich boosters from Omaha, but that he felt the estate tax (or Death Tax if you’re a republican) was horribly unfair because it was double taxation. Friend failed to mention that the estate tax affects a very small percentage of Nebraskans, and nationally an even smaller percentage of Americans. At the present moment the exemption amount is set at $1 million. Which means that an estate valued under $1 million dollars will not be taxed at all. If the exemption amount were raised to $2 million, only 150 people in the entire state would be affected by the Estate Tax. Think about that for a moment, this tax affects a tiny percent of the population, a group of people who’s total values make them millionares. But Senator Friend despises this tax, because it unfairly taxes people who “can’t afford it”
Quite a few Senators stood in support of a complete repeal of the Estate tax, enough that this liberal began to sweat a bit. Of course every Senator who stood in support for the amendment all claimed it was an unfair double taxation, albeit of those who can afford it the most.
“So where’s the hypocrisy?” You’re probably asking, and I respond to you, hold on a minute it’s coming.
Senator Friend withdrew the amendment, with the promise that he would revisit the issue at a more germane time in the proceedings, and we moved on Senator Chambers’
amendment. Senator Chambers, who has made many enemies during his 30 some years in the Legislature can make one claim that even those who hate him most cannot dispute. He fights for the little guy whenever possible. Chambers introduced an amendment that would lower the Sales Tax in Nebraska from 5.5% to 5%. Chambers rightfully touted this as a tax cut for EVERYONE from the richest among us, to the very poorest. What pushed my buttons the most was Senator Friend standing up in opposition to this amendment. If he’s truly against double taxation of the richest people in the state, surely he’s against what amounts to double taxation of everyone. But of course, Republican hypocrisy reared it’s ugly head, and after correctly pointing out that the Unicameral had actually promised to lower the tax rate once the state was out of the red when the voted to raise it a few years ago, Senators Chambers did one of the things he does best; he summed up clearly and accurately the lack of honesty that reverberates throughout the chamber on an all too regular basis. Chambers finished his comments directly after the vote with:
“I just saw compassion die.”
This Legislature talks a good game about caring for the downtrodden among us, but they rarely back up their talk with real action. Senator Chambers, Senator Lowen Kruse, and many others who truly have the best interest of their constituents and the state in mind are term limited, and I shudder to think what kinds of actions will be taken when they’re gone.